FormSubmit Alternative for Email Signup Forms
Looking for a FormSubmit alternative? See how to collect verified email signups with double opt-in, spam checks and CSV export. Get your endpoint free.
FormSubmit (formsubmit.co) is a good fit when you want a contact form that lands in your inbox. If your form is an email signup or a waitlist, you need more than an email. You need a stored list, double opt-in, spam checks and an export. Simple Signups (simple-signups.com) is a form backend built for that job. Switch if you are building a list of people. Stay with FormSubmit if you just want messages in your inbox.
FormSubmit vs Simple Signups at a glance
- What it stores: FormSubmit sends each submission to your email. Its docs describe an archive you can read through its API for 30 days. Simple Signups stores every signup in a list per campaign.
- Confirmation flow: FormSubmit asks you, the form owner, to confirm your form once. Simple Signups can ask each new subscriber to confirm their own address.
- Spam controls: FormSubmit uses reCAPTCHA by default, plus an optional honeypot and a phrase filter. Simple Signups uses a honeypot, a domain allow-list, rate limits, an MX check and optional Turnstile.
- Export: FormSubmit's docs describe an API archive, not a CSV export. Simple Signups exports your list as CSV or JSON.
- Webhooks: Both can call a webhook on each new submission.
- Free limits: FormSubmit's docs list unlimited forms and submissions. Simple Signups Free stores 100 submissions a month, plus a one-time 500 in your first 30 days.
- Setup: FormSubmit needs no account. Simple Signups needs a free account, a campaign and an allowed domain.
When FormSubmit is the right tool
FormSubmit is quick to start. Its home page says “Setup is easy and free.” There is no sign-up. You point your form's action at https://formsubmit.co/your@email.com and the messages go to that address. The first time you submit the form, FormSubmit sends you an email to confirm it.
That is a great match for a contact form. A visitor writes a message, and you read it in your inbox. FormSubmit also takes file uploads up to 10MB in total per form, and it has hidden fields for a redirect page, a subject line, a CC address and an auto-reply. If that is all you need, keep using it.
Simple Signups is not a contact-form-to-inbox tool, and it is not a form builder. You bring your own HTML. We store, check and export the signups.
Where it falls short for signup forms
A signup form has a different job. It builds a list you will email later. That brings three needs.
No verified list (double opt-in)
With FormSubmit, the confirmation email goes to you, the owner of the form. It checks that you own the inbox. It does not check the person who signs up. FormSubmit's docs do not describe a subscriber list with pending and confirmed states.
With Simple Signups, you can turn on double opt-in. A new address is stored as pending. It becomes confirmed when the subscriber clicks the link we send. You then email only people who said yes.
Spam on a public endpoint
A signup form sits on a public page, so bots find it. FormSubmit's docs say reCAPTCHA is on by default. You can turn it off per form with _captcha, but they suggest you keep it. You can also add a _honey field and a _blacklist of phrases.
Simple Signups runs its spam protection on every request:
- A honeypot field named
hp. Filled requests are dropped. - A domain allow-list. Posts from a hostname you did not add are rejected.
- Per-IP and per-campaign rate limits.
- An MX check, so an email domain with no mail server is refused.
- An optional Cloudflare Turnstile check on the Pro plan.
The anti-abuse docs list every check.
Getting your subscribers out (CSV, webhooks)
When you launch, you want your list in an email tool. FormSubmit's docs say its archive API is free but limited to 5 calls a day. Submissions are kept for 30 days, and uploaded files are not kept. Its docs do not describe a CSV export. It does offer a _webhook field that is called on each new submission.
Simple Signups keeps your list and exports it as CSV or JSON at any time. You can export only confirmed subscribers. You can also send each signup to a webhook.
Switch a signup form in 5 minutes
Here is a typical FormSubmit signup form. Your email address is in the action URL, and _honey is the honeypot.
<form action="https://formsubmit.co/you@example.com" method="POST"> <input type="email" name="email" required placeholder="you@example.com" /> <input type="text" name="_honey" style="display:none" /> <button type="submit">Subscribe</button></form>Here is the same form posting to a Simple Signups campaign. It sends the email to a list, not to your inbox.
<form action="https://simple-signups.com/api/subscribe" method="POST"> <input type="hidden" name="campaignId" value="pub_your_campaign_id" /> <input type="email" name="email" required placeholder="you@example.com" /> <input type="text" name="hp" tabindex="-1" autocomplete="off" style="position:absolute;left:-9999px" aria-hidden="true" /> <button type="submit">Subscribe</button></form>If you submit with JavaScript, send JSON with fetch. This replaces FormSubmit's AJAX URL. The endpoint answers with a stable error code you can show to the visitor.
const res = await fetch('https://simple-signups.com/api/subscribe', { method: 'POST', headers: { 'content-type': 'application/json' }, body: JSON.stringify({ campaignId: 'pub_your_campaign_id', email }),});if (!res.ok) { const err = await res.json().catch(() => ({})); throw new Error(err.error ?? res.statusText);}Three fields change:
_honeybecomeshp. Keep it hidden from people.- Your email address in the
actionURL becomes the hiddencampaignId. This is a public id, so it is safe in your HTML. - You add your site's domain to the campaign allow-list. Domains match exactly, so
example.comandwww.example.comare two entries.
Then work through this list:
- Create a free account and a campaign, then copy the campaign id.
- Add every hostname that serves the form to the allow-list.
- Change the
actionURL, add the hiddencampaignId, and rename_honeytohp. - Turn on email confirmation if you want a confirmed list.
- Submit a test address from your live site and check it in the dashboard.
The quickstart walks through each step. Point your signup form at a verified list instead of an inbox. Get your endpoint free.
Pricing compared
Both have a free plan. FormSubmit's home page says it is free, and its docs list unlimited forms and submissions. The Simple Signups Free plan stores 100 submissions a month, plus a one-time 500 in your first 30 days. It includes 2 campaigns, 3 domains per campaign and 1 webhook. Pro includes 5,000 submissions a month and 25 campaigns. See pricing for current prices.
Other FormSubmit alternatives
You may see other names when you search. Each is a hosted form backend. Most of them focus on sending form posts to an inbox or a dashboard.
- Formspree is a hosted form backend for form-to-inbox and dashboard use. Our Simple Signups vs Formspree post compares the two.
- Web3Forms is another hosted form backend, aimed mainly at sending form posts to an inbox.
- Getform is a hosted form backend, aimed mainly at form-to-inbox or dashboard use.
- Basin is a hosted form backend, also aimed mainly at form-to-inbox or dashboard use.
- Formspark is a hosted form backend in the same group, built mainly for form-to-inbox use.
Check each one's own site for prices and limits. If your site is on Netlify, read our Netlify Forms alternative guide.
FAQ
Is FormSubmit free?
Yes. Its home page says “Setup is easy and free.” Its docs list unlimited forms and unlimited submissions per email.
Is FormSubmit safe to use?
We can only tell you what it says about itself. Its help page says it uses Google reCAPTCHA v2 and v3, optional honeypots and a spam prevention system. Its docs also offer a random string you can use in place of your email address. Read its help and documentation pages and judge for yourself.
Does FormSubmit store submissions?
For a short time. Its docs say submissions are kept for 30 days and you can read them through its API, up to 5 times a day. Uploaded files are not kept. Its help page adds that posts made before you confirm the form are kept and sent once you confirm.
What is the best FormSubmit alternative for a newsletter signup form?
For a newsletter, pick a tool that keeps a list and checks each address. Simple Signups stores signups, can ask each person to confirm, and exports a clean CSV. See the newsletter signups use case for the setup.
Can I use FormSubmit without exposing my email address?
Yes. Its docs call this “invisible emails”. After you confirm your form, you get a random-looking string. You put that string in the action URL in place of your email address. With Simple Signups, your form only holds a public campaign id.