Netlify Forms Alternative for Signup Forms
Move off Netlify Forms without changing hosts. Swap one attribute for a hosted endpoint with double opt-in and spam protection.
Netlify Forms are found when Netlify parses your HTML at deploy time, so the form is tied to the host that builds your site. If you want a signup form that survives a host change and gives you a confirmed list, post the form to a hosted endpoint instead. Simple Signups (simple-signups.com) is one: the change is a form action, a hidden campaign id, and a domain allow-list entry.
What Netlify Forms does well
Netlify Forms needs almost no code. You add a netlify attribute, turn on form detection, and submissions show up in the Netlify UI. Spam filtering is built in, with Akismet always on, plus an optional honeypot field and reCAPTCHA 2. If your site lives on Netlify and you want a contact form that lands in a dashboard, it is a good fit.
Where it stops fitting a signup list
- It follows the host. Per the setup docs, form detection works on your deploys. Move the site to another host and you rebuild the form handling.
- Submissions are an inbox. You get rows to read, not a list with a pending and a confirmed state.
- No JSON body. The docs say Netlify Forms does not support JSON form data, so a
fetchcall must send a URL-encoded body. - Limits depend on your plan. Check Netlify's billing pages for your account. We do not quote their numbers here.
Swap the form for a Simple Signups endpoint
Here is a typical Netlify form. The netlify attribute is what ties it to the host.
<form name="signup" method="POST" data-netlify="true"> <input type="email" name="email" required placeholder="you@example.com" /> <button type="submit">Subscribe</button></form>Here is the same form posting to a Simple Signups campaign. Create the campaign in the dashboard, copy its public id, and add your site's domain to the allow-list. Domains match exactly, so example.com and www.example.com are different entries.
<form action="https://simple-signups.com/api/subscribe" method="POST"> <input type="hidden" name="campaignId" value="pub_your_campaign_id" /> <input type="email" name="email" required placeholder="you@example.com" /> <input type="text" name="hp" tabindex="-1" autocomplete="off" style="position:absolute;left:-9999px" aria-hidden="true" /> <button type="submit">Subscribe</button></form>If you submit with JavaScript, you can send JSON. No URL-encoding is needed, and the endpoint answers with a stable error code you can show to the visitor.
const res = await fetch('https://simple-signups.com/api/subscribe', { method: 'POST', headers: { 'content-type': 'application/json' }, body: JSON.stringify({ campaignId: 'pub_your_campaign_id', email }),});if (!res.ok) { const err = await res.json().catch(() => ({})); throw new Error(err.error ?? res.statusText);}Spam: Netlify built-ins versus ours
Netlify filters with Akismet and lets you add a honeypot and reCAPTCHA 2. Simple Signups runs these checks on every submission:
- A honeypot field named
hp. Filled requests are dropped. - The domain allow-list. Posts from a hostname you did not list are rejected.
- Per-IP and per-campaign rate limits.
- An MX check on the email domain, so addresses with no mail server are refused.
- An optional Cloudflare Turnstile challenge on the Pro plan.
The full list is in the anti-abuse docs. For the reasoning behind the layers, read how to stop spam on signup forms.
Double opt-in and a clean export
With email confirmation on, a new address is stored as pending. It becomes confirmed when the owner clicks the link we send. You can export the list as CSV or JSON, so you can send only to people who confirmed. The double opt-in walkthrough covers the flow step by step.
A short migration checklist
- Create a campaign in the dashboard and copy its public id.
- Add every hostname that serves the form to the campaign allow-list. Add the
wwwand apex names separately if you use both. - Replace the
netlifyattribute with theactionURL and the hiddencampaignIdinput. - Turn on email confirmation if you want a confirmed list, then submit a test address from your live site.
- Check the test row in the dashboard, then remove the old form from your Netlify setup.
Common questions
Does Netlify Forms work outside Netlify?
Netlify finds forms by parsing your HTML when it builds a deploy, according to its setup docs. A site built and hosted somewhere else does not get that step. A hosted endpoint has no such dependency, because the form just posts to a URL.
Can I use a form backend with a static site on another host?
Yes. The endpoint only needs your page to send an HTTP POST. That works from plain HTML, from a framework component, or from a script. Add the page's domain to the allow-list and you are done. The easiest backend for HTML forms and the Cloudflare Pages guide show the same pattern on other hosts.
Will my existing form markup keep working?
Mostly. Keep your own fields, layout and styles. You change the action, add the hidden campaign id, and use hp for the honeypot name. Optional fields such as firstName, lastName, tags and metadata are available when you want them.
What this does not cover
This post does not cover moving old Netlify submissions into Simple Signups. A new campaign starts with an empty list. Simple Signups is also not a contact-form-to-inbox tool or a form builder. You bring the HTML, and we store, verify and export the signups. If you want a form builder, read form backend vs form builder.
What it costs
The Free plan stores 100 submissions a month, plus a one-time 500 in your first 30 days. It includes 2 campaigns, 3 domains and 1 webhook. Pro includes 5,000 submissions a month and 25 campaigns. See pricing for the current prices.
Quick comparison
- Where it runs: Netlify Forms is tied to your Netlify deploys. A Simple Signups endpoint works from any host.
- What you get back: Netlify gives you submissions in its UI. Simple Signups gives you a list with pending and confirmed states.
- Request body: Netlify wants URL-encoded data. Simple Signups accepts JSON or form posts.
- Spam: Netlify has Akismet, honeypot and reCAPTCHA 2. Simple Signups has a honeypot, an allow-list, rate limits, an MX check and optional Turnstile.
Related
- Simple Signups vs Formspree.
- FormSubmit alternative for signup forms that post to an inbox today.
- Developer docs.